Annie Grace's This Naked Mind and the Immoderation Facet (N5)

Annie Grace's This Naked Mind takes a different route out of drinking than the usual grit-your-teeth abstinence. Grace, who quit after years of high-functioning heavy drinking, argues that willpower is the wrong tool because it fights the wrong thing. The craving, she says, is propped up by beliefs you never chose to examine, that alcohol relaxes you and rewards you. On her site she names the turning point: "Until I addressed those beliefs it was always going to be a battle." Change the belief and the wanting itself loosens. In the Big Five, the wanting sits on one facet.

The wanting is the Immoderation facet

The facet is Immoderation (N5), under Neuroticism, the difficulty resisting a craving once it fires. A high scorer feels the pull hard and reaches; a low scorer can let it pass. Most drinking advice aims straight at that pull and tells you to resist it with willpower, which is exhausting and tends to lose. Grace's move is to go under the craving to the belief feeding it. As she puts it in an interview, "I had a conscious desire to drink less but I had far more powerful feelings and beliefs that I needed alcohol to relax, socialise, network, have a good time even have sex." A high-N5 pull built on top of those beliefs is a lot easier to weaken by dismantling the beliefs than by out-muscling the urge.

What makes this more than positive thinking is that the beliefs are testable. Alcohol does not actually relax you; physiologically it does the opposite once it wears off, and the research on alcohol expectancy is blunt that a large share of the effect people feel is what they expected to feel. Grace's method is to keep asking what the drink genuinely delivers versus what you were taught it delivers, until the gap between them does the work. For a high-N5 person that reframe is a relief, because the strength of the craving is partly a learned story, not a verdict on your character, and stories can be rewritten.

We break the facet down on its own in Immoderation (N5). This Naked Mind is a self-directed approach, not treatment, and for anyone whose drinking is dangerous or physically dependent, Grace's method is not a substitute for medical help. What it offers a high-N5 reader is a second front. You do not only have to fight the urge head-on with a willpower budget that runs out by evening. You can also quietly take apart the reasons you believed you needed the drink, until fewer of them survive the question.

Read the book: This Naked Mind: Control Alcohol, Find Freedom, Discover Happiness & Change Your Life by Annie Grace.

See Where You Fall

Where do you actually fall? The 30-facet OCEAN personality test takes about 15 minutes and scores all five domains and the facets underneath them. Take the test

Research Citations